For investors · Colorado guide
Every headline number the rental calculator produces, explained like a friend would — then what’s specific to buying rentals in Colorado, and straight answers to the questions investors actually ask.
The metrics
Six come straight off the calculator and its PDF report. Two are quick screening checks you can do on a napkin before you bother running the full model.
Net operating income (NOI)
Effective gross income − operating expenses
Everything the property earns after vacancy and every operating cost, before the mortgage. NOI is the number lenders and appraisers anchor on because it describes the property, not your financing.
Cap rate
Annual NOI ÷ purchase price
The unleveraged yield. Useful for comparing two properties head-to-head. Front Range long-term rentals often trade in the mid single digits; higher cap rates usually mean more risk, more work, or a smaller market.
Cash flow
NOI − mortgage payment
What actually lands in (or leaves) your account each month. The calculator deducts a vacancy allowance (5% by default) and a maintenance budget (1% of value per year by default) before calling anything cash flow — because the roof does not care that you skipped the line item.
Cash-on-cash return
Annual cash flow ÷ total cash invested
Your first-year cash yield on the down payment and closing costs you put in. It ignores appreciation and principal paydown, which is exactly why it is a useful gut-check on a leveraged deal.
DSCR
Annual NOI ÷ annual debt service
Debt service coverage ratio. 1.00× means the property exactly covers its mortgage; many investor loan programs want roughly 1.20–1.25× or better. Below 1.00× you are subsidizing the property from your own pocket.
Total return & CAGR
Appreciation + principal paydown + cash flow
Cash flow is only one of three ways a rental pays you. The projection adds loan paydown and appreciation to get your total investment gain, then expresses it as return on investment and a compound annual growth rate (CAGR) over the years you own it.
Quick check by hand
Rent-to-price & GRM
Monthly rent ÷ price · Price ÷ annual rent
Screening shortcuts. The old "1% rule" (monthly rent at least 1% of price) is rare on the Front Range today; 0.7–0.9% is more typical, which is why the full expense model matters more than the rule of thumb.
Quick check by hand
Break-even occupancy
(Operating expenses + mortgage) ÷ gross income
The share of scheduled rent you must actually collect to cover every bill. Above 100% means the property loses money even fully rented at the rent you entered.
Colorado specifics
General information, not legal or tax advice. Rules vary by city, county and district and change — confirm the current version with the municipality, your CPA and your attorney.
How Colorado property tax works
Your bill is the county assessor’s actual value × the residential assessment rate × the local mill levy. For tax year 2026 the residential rate is 7.05% for school-district mills and 6.8% for other local-government mills (which also take 10% off the first $700,000 of value). A rental is assessed at the same residential rate as an owner-occupied home, and effective rates are among the lowest in the country — roughly half a percent of value statewide — but they swing widely with the mill levy. Values are reset in odd-numbered years. Pull the parcel from the county assessor and enter the real number; a seller’s senior or veteran exemption will not carry over to you.
Metro districts and HOAs
Many newer Front Range subdivisions sit inside a metropolitan district that financed the roads and utilities with bonds — and repays them with extra mills on your tax bill, sometimes doubling it versus an older neighborhood nearby. Check the mill levy on the parcel, not the city average. Colorado HOAs can also restrict or cap rentals; read the covenants before you close, and put the dues in the HOA line.
Rental licensing and short-term rentals
Colorado has no statewide landlord license, but cities do. Denver requires a residential rental license for any home rented for 30 days or more, with a passing third-party inspection; Boulder licenses rentals too. Short-term rentals are a separate world: Denver generally licenses them only in your primary residence, and many mountain and Front Range communities cap, zone or license them. The calculator models long-term rental income with a vacancy allowance; it is not an STR calculator.
No rent control, but real tenant law
State law bars cities and counties from enacting rent control, so there is no local cap on what you charge. That is not the same as few rules: Colorado now requires cause to evict or decline to renew most leases, limits rent increases to once in a 12-month period, caps late fees, enforces a warranty of habitability, and tightened security-deposit rules on January 1, 2026. Have a Colorado attorney review your lease.
Hail, wildfire and the insurance line
Colorado homeowners premiums are among the highest in the country, and the state Division of Insurance attributes roughly a quarter to half of a typical premium to hail. Wind and hail deductibles are often a percentage of the dwelling value rather than a flat amount, and an older roof can change the quote or the coverage. In the foothills and mountains, confirm the property is insurable for wildfire before you are under contract. Get a real landlord-policy quote for the address.
House-hacking a 2–4 unit
Live in one unit and rent the rest, and owner-occupied financing with a much lower down payment may apply. The calculator models a pure investment purchase; for a house-hack, enter only the rent you will collect from the other units and ask Dominick which programs fit.
Real rent, not an online estimate.
Pull three comparable leases, or ask a local property manager what the unit rents for today.
Real tax, not the seller’s tax.
Look up the parcel and its mill levy — metro district included.
An insurance quote.
Get a landlord-policy quote for that address, wind/hail deductible included — not a guess.
Reserves you’d actually keep.
Lenders usually want to see cash reserves after closing anyway.
The DSCR line.
If it’s under 1.0×, the property is a bet on appreciation. Know that going in.
A loan officer’s eyes on the PDF.
Send it to Dominick. He can walk you through how investment-property financing could look for these numbers before you write the offer.
Investor FAQ
The “why is my cash flow negative” question, the “what’s a good return” question, and the “what do you do with my data” question. All of it, in plain English.
Using the calculator
Is the calculator really free, and do you collect my information?
Yes, and no. There is no email wall, no account and no forms, and this site uses no analytics, no trackers and no cookies. Every number you type stays in your browser, and the PDF report is generated on your own device — nothing is uploaded. Nothing about your scenario reaches Dominick unless you choose to send it to him yourself.
Where do the default numbers come from?
They are a sample Front Range duplex scenario, chosen to be realistic rather than flattering: a Colorado-level property-tax estimate of 0.6% of the price per year, a landlord insurance estimate priced for hail country at 0.75% per year, a 5% vacancy allowance, 8% property management and a maintenance budget of 1% of value per year. The 7% interest rate is a sample, not a quote. At that sample rate the scenario runs slightly negative, which is common on the Front Range with 25% down. Tax, insurance, maintenance and closing costs auto-scale with the purchase price until you type your own figure. Replace every one of them with figures from the actual listing, county records, an insurance quote and local rent comps.
What does the PDF report include?
A Fairway-branded, letter-size report built from exactly what you entered. The first page is the snapshot: cap rate, return on investment, cash-on-cash, monthly cash flow, DSCR and initial investment, short plain-English readings of the key numbers, and the full purchase, financing, income and expense breakdown. The second page covers your hold period: future value, projected cap rate, total equity, total investment gain, return on investment and CAGR, where the return comes from, and a chart of cumulative total return by year. After that comes the year-by-year cash flow table (ten years per page) and the disclosures. Every page carries Dominick Romig’s contact details and NMLS number, so you can forward it straight to him, your agent or a partner.
Can I save or share a scenario?
Download the PDF — that is the saved scenario. Because nothing is stored on a server, there is no account to log into and no scenario history; if you change a number, generate a fresh report.
The numbers
What is a good cash-on-cash return for a Colorado rental?
Opinions vary, and the honest answer is “it depends what else you could do with the money.” Many investors target 6–10% cash-on-cash on a leveraged long-term rental, accept less for a property in a strong appreciation corridor, and want more for a heavy-rehab or rural deal. On the Front Range, where prices are high relative to rents, thin or even negative cash-on-cash with solid appreciation and principal paydown is common — which is why the calculator and report show total return and CAGR, not just cash flow.
Why does the calculator care so much about DSCR?
Debt service coverage ratio — net operating income divided by the annual principal and interest payment — is the metric investor loan programs are built on. A DSCR of 1.25× means the property earns 25% more than it owes the lender each year. Many investment-property programs look for roughly 1.20–1.25× or better; some DSCR loans allow lower with a bigger down payment or higher rate. If your DSCR is below 1.0×, the property does not pay for itself.
Why is my cash flow negative when the rent covers the mortgage?
Because the mortgage is not the only bill. Property tax, insurance, vacancy, maintenance and management typically eat 35–50% of rent on a Colorado rental. The calculator deducts all of those before the mortgage. A property that “covers the mortgage” but not the reserves will cash flow on paper and bleed the first time a hailstorm takes the roof and the deductible comes due.
What’s the difference between cap rate and cash-on-cash?
Cap rate ignores financing: it is net operating income divided by purchase price, so it compares properties regardless of how they are bought. Cash-on-cash includes financing: it is annual cash flow after the mortgage divided by the cash you actually put in. Cap rate tells you about the property; cash-on-cash tells you about your deal.
Financing a Colorado investment property
How much do I need to put down on an investment property?
More than on a home you will live in. Conventional investment-property loans commonly require 15–25% down depending on the number of units, and 2–4 unit properties sit at the higher end. Rates run higher than owner-occupied pricing, and lenders usually want cash reserves after closing. If you plan to live in one unit of a 2–4 unit property, owner-occupied programs with much lower down payments may apply — ask Dominick.
What is a DSCR loan?
A loan qualified primarily on the property’s rental income (its debt service coverage ratio) rather than your personal tax returns. It is popular with self-employed investors and people building a portfolio. Pricing and down-payment requirements differ from conventional loans. Ask Dominick how the same scenario compares under a DSCR loan and a conventional investment-property loan.
What happens when I reach out to Dominick?
Only what you choose to share. This site has no forms and collects nothing, so nothing is sent automatically. Texting or calling 970-787-3110 uses your own phone, emailing uses your own mail app, and applying takes you to Fairway Home Mortgage’s own secure systems, which are governed by Fairway’s privacy policy. If you want Dominick to look at a deal, send him the PDF or just the key numbers — whatever you’re comfortable sharing.
Is this only for Colorado properties?
The math works anywhere, but the defaults, the notes beside each field and the guide on this page are written for Colorado. Dominick is licensed in Colorado, Arizona, Florida, Michigan, Nebraska, Texas & Wyoming; if the property is in one of his other states, replace the tax and insurance defaults with local figures and ask him what is different there.
Does this site give tax or legal advice?
No. Depreciation, passive-loss rules, Colorado assessment rates and mill levies, rental licensing and landlord-tenant law all affect real returns and all change. The guide on this page explains the concepts; a CPA and an attorney tell you how they apply to you.
Still wondering about something? Text Dominick at 970-787-3110 or see other ways to reach him. Buying a home to live in? The homebuyer FAQ covers that.
Investment calculator results and the downloadable report are estimates for illustrative and educational purposes only, based entirely on the figures you enter. They are not a quote, rate lock, pre-qualification, pre-approval, appraisal, or investment, tax or legal advice, and accuracy is not guaranteed. Actual rates, payments, taxes, insurance, rents, vacancy, expenses and property values vary by property and scenario. Sample rates shown are not an offer. Consult a licensed loan officer, tax professional and attorney before purchasing an investment property. Real estate investing involves risk, including possible loss of principal. Past appreciation and rent growth do not guarantee future results. Projections use constant annual growth rates you choose and do not account for income taxes, depreciation recapture, capital gains, refinancing, major repairs, or periods of extended vacancy. Regulated by the Colorado Division of Real Estate.
Ready when you are
Text Dominick the address and your numbers — or the PDF — and he’ll walk you through how financing an investment property could work for you. No pressure, no obligation.
Applications happen on Fairway's secure site — never here.
